I decided to preemptively replace my PlanePower AL12-EI60 alternator at 513 hours. It whines like a coyote despite the alternator filter, whereas my backup B&C BC410-H is as quiet as a mouse. Late last year, B&C released the SF601 internally regulated alternator which is what I went with.
Here are the differences I noted between the B&C and PlanePower. No claims on if any of these are significant in any way.
- The B&C has no low voltage indicator light output. So I needed to redesign my panel indicator board.
- The B&C tension arm bracket is longer, so I had to translate the forward heat muff outboard so its SCAT tube doesn't impinge on the bracket.
- The B&C brackets are not cadmium plated.
- B&C alternator is about 2 ounces heavier than the PlanePower.
- The bolt that holds the B&C alternator to the boss bracket is smaller in diameter.
- There is no bracket between the starter and B&C alternator like for the PlanePower (part V-1002 on plans page 43-12, shown below in red); Part V-1002 won't fit. Looking at plans drawing, I'm curious why Van's included that bracket and why B&C didn't.
On the phone, the B&C tech told me that my alternator belt would need to be changed since the stock belt isn't the right length. Turns out that they sent me the same Dayco 15355 belt that I already was using, so no belt change was necessary.
My new B&C alternator has no whine. Pilot happy.